US, Qatar, Egypt Float Talks, but Hamas is Still Insisting on All or Nothing

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is under pressure as intense negotiations continue for a possible month-long humanitarian pause in the Gaza conflict, aimed at facilitating the release of hostages.

He rejected outright Hamas demands for a total Israeli withdrawal and end of fighting as a condition for releasing hostages. “In exchange for the release of our hostages, Hamas demands the end of the war, the withdrawal of our forces from Gaza, the release of all the murderers and rapists,” Netanyahu said in a statement. “And leaving Hamas intact.”

“I reject outright the terms of surrender of the monsters of Hamas,” Netanyahu said. But quietly, he had launched an Israeli initiative for a middle ground, hinting as much in meetings with hostage families in the past days.

The United States, through Middle East envoy Brett McGurk, is actively involved in the talks, supporting a longer humanitarian pause. Qatar and Egypt are also playing key roles in the mediation efforts.

Hamas, on the other hand, is seeking assurances for a permanent ceasefire agreement, emphasizing the need for an end to aggression and a complete withdrawal from the Gaza Strip. Despite showing openness to discussions, Hamas rejected an Israeli proposal that would end the war if six senior leaders, including Yahya Sinwar and Mohamed al-Deif, were removed from Gaza.

The situation remains tense, with the Israeli military suffering significant casualties in recent days, and the families of approximately 130 hostages held since Hamas’ incursion exerting pressure for a resolution. The Israeli government remains firm on its stance of not agreeing to a ceasefire that leaves Hamas in power in Gaza.

The negotiations have seen some progress, with both sides coming closer to agreeing on a 30-day process that includes the release of all hostages, more aid to Gaza, and the release of Palestinian prisoners. However, bridging the gap in positions remains a challenge, with Hamas concerned about Israel possibly resuming fighting after the release of civilian hostages.